[There's something unnerving about that sailor. The way he doesn't seem to flinch or fret about the impending sinking of the ship they're on, or all the dirty little details that go along with it. He doesn't flinch when Luffy hits his shoulder and something tells him the kid wasn't necessarily holding back.

He's the problem. He's the one who should be left behind to fend for himself, as far as Buggy is concerned.

He's a little more hesitant when Luffy tells him to pick one. He knows which one to say, but-- it's more the paranoia that Luffy could save the other sailors and he'd be stuck with... whatever is going on with this one alone. Can Luffy even get seven sailors on his row boat or will they have to use Buggy's? He huffs, jaw tightening as he debates his options. He could make a run for his boat. Let Luffy sort it out. But he's probably not as easy to ditch as the chef and Zoro were.

Besides, they're stuck together. The only ones from their world that he knows. Maybe Buggy doesn't think it's all that smart to entirely burn those bridges, unfortunately.

In the end, he rolls his shoulders and nods his head towards their mystery friend on the end.]

That one. Your little pal.

[He gives a pointed look.]

Come back down as soon as you get the others settled, yeah? I'll let you know who to bring down next.

[Don't you dare leave him to drown, Luffy, or he'll throw you in the water himself.]