( The sailor receiving the shoulder punch barely even reacts and Luffy can tell instinctively something isn't right here. The other sailors are scared, they flinch and cower at the slightest movement. This one doesn't and when Luffy stares into those eyes he knows that this is the one.

But now what?

Luffy looks over at his name, knowing Buggy has seen it too. Buggy rarely uses his name, it's normally champ, pal, buddy, and Luffy always responds the same way by calling the clown by anything but his actual name. )

I dunno Buggy, this is tricky. ( He gets back to his feet, moving back to stand near the clown. The idea of violence is still not sitting right with Luffy but he knows their time is running out as the ship gives an almighty creak, the listing pronounced enough that the few remaining things on shelves begin to roll from them if the random smashes in the distance is anything to go by. )

You know what? You're right, we should talk to them one by one. Pick one to start with, I'll take the rest out on deck. ( And hopefully get them all on the rowboat.... )