[Allison's head tips to the side slightly because on the one hand, while her atonement also has something to do with Pride, she's not sure that this approach is atonement so much as punishment.]

Wouldn't it be easier to uplift his competition instead? What is destroying him going to gain the people he hurt?

[This is probably not the question to ask, especially when she's unclear how to handle her own cursed request, but it's something that comes to mind.]

It's your curse to resolve, so I'm not judging but this sounds more like a punishment than reparations.